Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Food, Inc. Review


Positive Review:  For Health or Profit, But Not Necessarily for Both http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=105152916
The most positive review of Food, Inc. was given by National Public Radio (NPR), a generally neutral news source.  The reviewer, David Edelstein, had nothing negative to say about the movie.  The title gives readers of the review a clue at Edelstein’s opinion, “For Health or Profit, But Not Necessarily for Both.”  The title shows that Edelstein completely agrees with the ideas expressed in the movie.  Edelstein feels that the movie is thought-provoking, even saying that “Every line, every frame makes you choke on your popcorn…”  Edelstein also calls the scale of Food, Inc. “mind-blowing.”  The words he uses throughout the article proves his opinion about Food, Inc. and the ideas expressed in Food, Inc.

Neutral Review:  Meet Your New Farmer:  Hungry Corporate Giant http://movies.nytimes.com/2009/06/12/movies/12food.html
The most neutral review, highlighting both positive and negative aspects of the movie, was in The New York Times, a slightly left-leaning newspaper.  The reviewer, Manohla Dargis, seems to completely agree with the content of Food, Inc. but does not always agree with how the content is portrayed.  This reviewer again references popcorn in proving that the movie is mind-blowing, saying, “Nothing says horror like one of those tubs of artificially buttered, nonorganic popcorn…”  She also refers to the lessons learned in Food, Inc. as “unappetizing.”  A third example of Dargis’ feelings about the content of the movie is calling the documentary “informative” and “often infuriating.”  But Dargis does not agree with how this content is portrayed.  She calls the graphics “dopey” and refers to speakers in the movie as “talking heads.”  She also feels that a lot of the content in Food, Inc. is glossed over; that it could be covered much more in depth.  Dargis describes her feelings by saying “…the movie stops before it really gets started…”  Dargis’ review is inherently neutrally, agreeing with all of the content but not with how the content is portrayed.

The most negative review of Food, Inc., by Kyle Smith of the New York Post, finds the movie to be unoriginal and predictable.  From beginning to end, Smith disagrees with the portrayal of the content in the movie.  In the second line of the article, Smith states that the movie relies on “now-familiar gross-out tactics.”  He even goes so far as to call parts of the movie “shrill and pointless.”  He also feels that the movie presents no new information, saying that “the movie offers very little that food radicals don’t already know.”  Smith also takes issue with the fact that issues aren’t pursued deeply enough, similar to the feelings presented by Dargis in her New York Times’ review.  Smith concludes his article by disagreeing with what he feels is the take home message of the movie:  that everyone should buy expensive organic food.  This review is very against Food, Inc., both in subject and how content is portrayed.                      

No comments:

Post a Comment